"පරිශීලක සාකච්ඡාව:බිඟුවා" හි සංශෝධන අතර වෙනස්කම්

Page contents not supported in other languages.
විකිපීඩියා වෙතින්
Content deleted Content added
54 පේළිය: 54 පේළිය:
::::I was just drawing a parallel or was quoting an analogy. You must be aware certain templates or articles are prevented from editing by anonymous editors or by editors who are not administrators. That is because they are used in lot of places and if a wrong code is placed it will upset the whole system. Hence Wikipedia had made its own rules to prevent such catastrophes. Any system is having such self-defensive rules. Even the human body is having such system called immune system. To stregthen this system in case of a huge attack by bacterial or virul agents, a physician administers drugs. Saline Solution is one such. However, if the Saline Solution itself is impure and consists of bacteria, virus or fungus it will do more harm to patient than good. In Wikipedia we have immunity system. Administrators help this immunity system. As you claim you have introduced this "code" to help the system. But, the stewards claim that your code had introduced certain abilities to monitor activities of users. This will breach the immunity of users within wikipedia and can lead to ultimate demise of the system. As a physician should be careful about the "quality" of Saline, you too should have taken more care about suitability of your "code" and possible harmful effects. When the patient's case is aggravated, a physician can claim that he did the routine thing of administering Saline. You too tell similarly you just tried to help the users. However, we expect much more responsible behavior. That is what I wanted to say. Thanks. ---[[User:ශ්වෙත|ශ්වෙත]] ([[User talk:ශ්වෙත|talk]]) 14:58, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)
::::I was just drawing a parallel or was quoting an analogy. You must be aware certain templates or articles are prevented from editing by anonymous editors or by editors who are not administrators. That is because they are used in lot of places and if a wrong code is placed it will upset the whole system. Hence Wikipedia had made its own rules to prevent such catastrophes. Any system is having such self-defensive rules. Even the human body is having such system called immune system. To stregthen this system in case of a huge attack by bacterial or virul agents, a physician administers drugs. Saline Solution is one such. However, if the Saline Solution itself is impure and consists of bacteria, virus or fungus it will do more harm to patient than good. In Wikipedia we have immunity system. Administrators help this immunity system. As you claim you have introduced this "code" to help the system. But, the stewards claim that your code had introduced certain abilities to monitor activities of users. This will breach the immunity of users within wikipedia and can lead to ultimate demise of the system. As a physician should be careful about the "quality" of Saline, you too should have taken more care about suitability of your "code" and possible harmful effects. When the patient's case is aggravated, a physician can claim that he did the routine thing of administering Saline. You too tell similarly you just tried to help the users. However, we expect much more responsible behavior. That is what I wanted to say. Thanks. ---[[User:ශ්වෙත|ශ්වෙත]] ([[User talk:ශ්වෙත|talk]]) 14:58, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)
:I have emailed the stewards mailing list asking for more input on how to proceed, I will keep you guys up to date as soon as I can. <i><b>[[User:Snowolf|<font color = "darkmagenta">Snowolf</font>]] <sup><small>[[m:User:Snowolf|<font color = "darkmagenta">How can I help?</font>]]</small></sup></b></i> 21:32, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)
:I have emailed the stewards mailing list asking for more input on how to proceed, I will keep you guys up to date as soon as I can. <i><b>[[User:Snowolf|<font color = "darkmagenta">Snowolf</font>]] <sup><small>[[m:User:Snowolf|<font color = "darkmagenta">How can I help?</font>]]</small></sup></b></i> 21:32, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)
::Any updates? --&nbsp;[[පරිශීලක:බිඟුවා|<span style="color:BLUE;"><b>බිඟුවා</b></span>]]&nbsp;[[User talk:බිඟුවා|<sup><span style="color:RED;">සාකච්ඡාව</span></sup>]] 03:30, 4 ජූලි 2012 (යූටීසී)

03:30, 4 ජූලි 2012 තෙක් සංශෝධනය

අපි නොදන්න චෙස්



සංරක්‍ෂිත ලේඛණ

විකිපීඩියා සාකච්ඡාව:තෝරාගත් ලිපි/වත්මන් හී අන්තර්ගතය විකිපීඩියා:තෝරාගත් ලිපි/වත්මන්හී යොදන්න පුලුවන්ද, මොකද ඒක අපිළිවෙලයි. වචනෙයි රූපෙයි විතරයි තියෙන්නේ, පාද තලයත් නැහැ. ස්තුතියි! සිඳු ( සාකච්ඡාව / @ ) 13:33, 6 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

මේ වගේ වැඩ පොදු තැනක සංවාදයට ලක් කරලා පරිපාලක මහතෙකුට දැනුම් දෙන්න. -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 03:18, 8 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

ඔබේ සහයෝගය අවශ්‍යයි!

https://translations.launchpad.net/ubuntu

https://launchpad.net/~pkavinda ස්තුතියි! සිඳු ( සාකච්ඡාව / @ ) 02:02, 19 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

Desysop and tracking scripts

Hi. In my role as steward, I have proceeded to the emergency removal of your +sysop flags on siwiki, siwiktionary and siwikibooks pending discussion with you about the matter which I'll address in a moment. I would ask you to reply here and we can keep all discussion here in this section. You appear to have added an obfuscated javascript to common.js on siwiki, siwikibooks and siwiktionary, which pointed to sett-decoder.appspot.com and loaded google analytics. It is my understanding that in this way, all of our users' were tracked by said google analytics in an egregious violation of the privacy policy. Please explain your actions. Snowolf How can I help? 20:21, 26 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

Hi, This was not to be developed to tracing anyone. Original Issue is for Sinhala Language it can not be read & write Sinhala Unicode characters without installing Sinhala Unicode. Whenever new reader comes to a Sinhala Wikipedia he Only see that some boxes nor more a single word. This happens frequently. The reason is that system which they are using not installed Sinhala Unicode. So a Developer bhasha has developed a JavaScript which can be done on-fly. if the system is not installed Sinhala Unicode, this script will automatically do the job. In that script it was included this Google analytic section & I got informed by another Wikipedian about that. I have informed this to the Developer & he is agreed to remove that tracing. He is working on that. I think you can understand what I have done. Thank you. -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 03:07, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
That doesn't address why you obfuscated the code in the common.js Snowolf How can I help? 03:11, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
That Script needs to run every time for all users. Where do you think it can be keep? -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 03:13, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
Why is it needed for all users? How about just keeping the link in the sitenotice to the page containing information about fixing the problem? Was there even consensus for such a change? Hazard-SJ (talk) 03:18, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
that Script needs to run machine which are not installed Sinhala Unicode. SO it needs to check. Yes I agree that tracking is wrong. -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 03:24, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
I'm asking why you felt the need to obfuscate the javascript. Snowolf How can I help? 03:25, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
I'm Sorry! Without modifying commons.js how it can be get effects for all users? just like උදවු:මූලිකාදර්ශය. This script need to keep in Server. Then it not need to modify commons.js please explain what is the question? -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 03:32, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

The question is, why did you obfuscate the code for the wikis (and inserted it without letting the community know and even without edit summary and code comment telling what it does?). Furthermore I've spent some time analyzing the scripts yesterday and found that you are not only using a custom script to import the script to the projects (siwikt, siwiki), but also imported a script (https://sett-decoder.appspot.com/settdeco.js) which is customized for use on Wikimedia projects (eg. it checks document.location.hostname == "si.wiktionary.org" || document.location.hostname == "si.wikibooks.org" || document.location.hostname == "si.wikipedia.org") but loads google analytics. Could you please explain why you did all the things mentioned in my post (especially why a custom script for Wikimedia which explicit loads google analytics) and why you didn't ask for a valid free license to use only the actual decoder part of those scripts directly on the Wikis? - Hoo man (talk) 09:37, 27 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

Actually I'm not the one who created this script. This is a script I have got from [1] to use for our task, it was already obfuscated. I can ask for a free license for wikimedia Projects. So I'm not the one who obfuscate this. Did I answer you? -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 08:28, 28 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
No, there are still open questions, the script you used was especially customized for use on the Wikimedia sites, and it's different from the one given on the site, please explain how exactly you got hold of that script. In case you didn't knew what it did, why did you just use it? With your previous JavaScript experience, you should have seen that it's obfuscated... there are users like me available on meta who can help local communities with such things, so you could have asked, if you haven't been sure. But activating a script for ALL users without knowing what it does is a high risk, there are many ways in which that could be abused. Maybe you could tell the full story of how the scripts made their way into the wikis, so that we don't need to ask so many further questions, cheers Hoo man (talk) 14:19, 28 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
OK. Now Story Comes. I think you are full aware of the Issue. the Issue was we can't see the Content without having Sinhala Unicode. So the solution was developed by http://settdeco.bhasha.lk/. Then I have ask them to give their solution to apply for Sinhala Wikipedia. Since that is a commercial it needs to have a valid/free license. So they have customized their scripts for siwiki, siwikibooks and siwiktionary separately. I have used those scripts as a solution for our Issue. That is all. Yes I have noticed that script was obfuscated & I have done an investigation on that. I noticed that Google analytic sections as well. I have question about that from them & they said the need to track about their script usage. So I though it was not a problem & seems that is wrong. Then later time some wiki-Admin has removed the code. Then I have asked http://settdeco.bhasha.lk/ to give me a solution without this Google Analytic & with Free licensee. Now they concerning about that. -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 03:54, 29 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

Please investigate the allegation against පරිශීලක :බිඟුවා fast as possible and take necessary action. If he is innocent release him and restore his rights & position. If he had spied on Wikipedia community and you all think it is a punishable offence, take suitable punitive action. I personally do not like "Stalemate" situations. --- ශ්වෙත (talk) 01:47, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]

Dear ශ්වෙත,
Its good if we can clarify this. But unfortunately I am not technically sound on matters related to this.
About sinhala unicode, I know that Official Site to support unicode for local langages of Sri Lanka is giving solutions for people using OS that does not support Sinhala partially of fully.
Hope technically sound guys will give their inputs.
Singhalawap (talk) 05:05, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
I am also ignorant about these IT matters. However according to my understanding, පරිශීලක :බිඟුවා had used his IT knowledge & skills and powers as an Administrator had done some changes which he claims "will assist all Sinhala Wikipedians to write in Sinhala". I am not aware of such a necessity or such an inclusion in Sinhala Wikipedia. I beleive not only me none of us in Sinhala Wikipedia were notified about such an "assistance". Now, if we disregard that issue, what stewards say, according to what I understand, is that through this "code", පරිශීලක :බිඟුවා could gather information about usage by all Wikipedians and thus he could spy on us. They say this is irregular. As you say, for Sinhala Unicode there is official assistance and I do not know why පරිශීලක :බිඟුවා sought third party assistance to "assist all of us" "without our knowledge". ---ශ්වෙත (talk) 05:54, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
Guys, you can continue discussion here, But I would like to add a word as well. So you guys will not have any Unicode Issues means that read & write Sinhala letters in this Wikipedia since you already installed it. But new comer comes, most of them just come to si.wiki & only noticed that check boxes since they don't have installed Sinhala Unicode. Yes There is a notice for installation. Do you think how many of them want to do an installation to see the content of a web page. Instead of installing what they do is just move a web page which can be read. Even if want to do a request like "pls do something to make this page read" how they will find a page with these check boxes. if you want to have an experience please uninstall you Sinhala Unicode package from your machine & think as a new comer. This is not assist for you all guys. But it needs to check your machine has installed Unicode already. It has already implemented a tool to write in Sinhala see this උදවු:මූලිකාදර්ශය. This is to read the pages. Nothing else. That is Only thing I was trying to do. So it is up to you. Bye. -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 08:36, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
If you administer Saline to save a patient, you must make sure that it is free of fungus, bacteria or virus. Otherwise it will make more harm to the patient and may loose life. Here also, it is the same.---ශ්වෙත (talk) 09:58, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
ශ්වෙත, Can you explain a bit of your words? -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 13:36, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
I was just drawing a parallel or was quoting an analogy. You must be aware certain templates or articles are prevented from editing by anonymous editors or by editors who are not administrators. That is because they are used in lot of places and if a wrong code is placed it will upset the whole system. Hence Wikipedia had made its own rules to prevent such catastrophes. Any system is having such self-defensive rules. Even the human body is having such system called immune system. To stregthen this system in case of a huge attack by bacterial or virul agents, a physician administers drugs. Saline Solution is one such. However, if the Saline Solution itself is impure and consists of bacteria, virus or fungus it will do more harm to patient than good. In Wikipedia we have immunity system. Administrators help this immunity system. As you claim you have introduced this "code" to help the system. But, the stewards claim that your code had introduced certain abilities to monitor activities of users. This will breach the immunity of users within wikipedia and can lead to ultimate demise of the system. As a physician should be careful about the "quality" of Saline, you too should have taken more care about suitability of your "code" and possible harmful effects. When the patient's case is aggravated, a physician can claim that he did the routine thing of administering Saline. You too tell similarly you just tried to help the users. However, we expect much more responsible behavior. That is what I wanted to say. Thanks. ---ශ්වෙත (talk) 14:58, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
I have emailed the stewards mailing list asking for more input on how to proceed, I will keep you guys up to date as soon as I can. Snowolf How can I help? 21:32, 30 මැයි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]
Any updates? -- බිඟුවා සාකච්ඡාව 03:30, 4 ජූලි 2012 (යූටීසී)[reply]